Deej said:
A bay 16 ticket is $16.25 per game, how much beer do students usually consume at 1 Mariners game? Probably more than $16 worth I'd say!
Including the other benefits you get with your membership I reckon it's reasonable.
To quote lock stock "it's a deal, it's a steal, it's the sale of the f**king century"!
Full time students have *less money* than full time workers.
It is a *less good deal* than it is for full time workers.
It's terrific value for workers, it's much less terrific for students (for whom getting a saving up to $70 or close to half the price of membership and getting membership elsewhere in the ground is relatively attractive as a consequence).
All of us workers can just pay what we would have paid anyway, while frankly students are getting screwed.
Is that so hard to grasp?
When I was a full time undergrad student I probably wouldn't have been able to afford to get membership.
After work and government assistance, I had about $500 per fortnight clear after tax. From that Id pay $300 rent. Making ends meet with essentially $200 disposable income per fortnight (which also had to cover bills, train tickets, food etc) means that you look at an annual cost of $190 with much less enthusiasm than one of $120.
Talk of but you save a seat for the future or its cheaper than overseas doesnt really cut it when thats more than a months worth in train tickets youre talking about.
I certainly wouldnt have been drinking $16 worth of beer at a game if I were a student. Others might, thats up to them, I preferred being able to buy groceries at the end of the week.
From my personal experience I would say that it would surprise me if there were no students going bugger that and taking the cheaper option. Its not like theyre going to be feted like kings for making a bigger sacrifice, or are we going to give them pride of place because they demonstrated a greater commitment by spending more of their hard-earned than everyone else?
It's a debate of more academic interest to me now as I'm not clearing a mere $500 a fortnight these days, and there are mitigating points but in the end it's still stupid and unnecessary, and given both
Newcastle and
Sydney offer concessions so theres no reason for us not to.
Jeff (LouMacari) said:
ok, I get that you don't get it... move on.
Nobody's made a half-decent argument more like - you must 'not get' my criticisms. Had the tone in this discussion from some quarters not been so condescending I probably would have moved on before now.