I
Of the players expiring this year, we've not yet seen Bingham, Fletcher or McDonald.
Barring surprises, I'd be fairly surprised if we extended any of them, and of the players we have seen I'd be surprised if we extended Adelson (unless on a NYL full-time gig - he's only 20!), Appiah-Kubi, Faty, Ferreira (unless he starts really producing!), Necevski or Tavares.
Watch for players on this list suddenly discovering opportunities in Malaysia, Thailand and Singapore in January.
I think Tavares suffers because he and Faty seem to be a package deal. Their retention or not will be determined by the weaker player's performance. Faty is too up and down.
I think Montgomery, Neill, O’Donovan, Poscoliero and Roux are all going to be effectively on-notice too.
I would guess that they'd be re-signed, but if they have an extended poor run of form or injury...
I don't see why o'Donovan would be on notice - he's proven that he can hit the target if he's given the ball and he provides a lot in work-rate... At the very least I'd think they'd be interested in keeping him on as a Danny McBreen-style backup, although I think he's a bit off slowing down to that extend.
I know Roux has his detractors, but when he's good, he's good and decent full backs are notoriously hard to find... Not to mention, one forgets that he's only 23 - he's still got a bit of developing to do.
I think it'd be a mistake to let Posco go - we're not exactly experiencing a dearth of decent CBs and I think he has the ability to provide... I'd agree with Neill and Monty though - I'm not sure if Neill's youth and potential might save him.
As I see the group though, I'm half expecting to see a wholesale renewal of some of the younger boys,
Adelson
Appiah-Kubi
Bingham
Buhagiar
Based on the general feedback, I'd say Adelson is worth a cheap punt, in spite of his injuries - seems like he'll more than push for a starting birth when fit and seeing as we've already invested this much in him, may as well keep going
... Besides, between him/Roux and Galloway/Neill we'd have something as rare as workable depth at FB.
Appiah-Kubi seems to have been performing fairly well at the start of the season, although I'll admit to not being entirely certain about the quality of having a third-string LW floating around, if we assume that Ferreira is let go and replace.
Bingham - from memory he's been on the bench - problem for him is that Roy's been performing pretty well in his position and is match fit - that doesn't mean that we don't need a backup for the role though, and arguably, at this point, Bingers is the better option... Plus again, he's still fairly young.
Trent is probably the most obvious one - been getting game time and doing pretty well, all things considered, would be outright stupid to let him go, if he's willing to re-sign.