Ok, you don’t want to saddle yourself with players on 2 year deals who may prove they’re not up to it
If you don’t think someone can be an acceptable squad player for 2 years I question why you’d sign them. You might get a few duds but we carry squad players we never see anyway. I heard we trialled a lot of NPL players and came out with some good prospects. A one year deal is madness and gambling against your recruitment.
If he goes and we don't gain financially from it, we need a "please explain" from the club.
Why would we benefit from it? A 1 year deal doesn’t give any chance of making money on a player. When they signed for us we had leverage to push an extra year, once they’re here and gaining attention we have none and they have it all. We could have had Millar locked down for another year relatively cheap but instead he’s about to significantly increase his wage elsewhere.