First A-League player to rack up 100 goals and he's put plenty past us, including a hat-trick at Victory. I agree he's probably not a good culture fit for us though.
I honestly don't see this argument. I mean, we had O'Donovan for a start, who is easily the filthiest player since Muscat and one of the few players who intentionally tries to cause serious harm.
Hutcho was hardly innocent.....I'm not worried about his YC offences - he was an enforcer after all but he didn't try to really injure anybody, but in his later years he just shadowed the ref abusing him all game.
Matty Simon also tends to focus more on the referee's alleged deficiencies than his own - and let's be honest, he starts a lot of shit on the field the last few years - 3rd man into a confrontation if nothing else.
As a club, we've been amongst the worst teams for yellow and red cards for a number of seasons now.
We had Asdrubal who was, for the (thankfully) short time he was here, was one of the biggest divers in the league.
And we had...was it Baro? (EDIT: No, Brama - thanks
@turbo) Who was getting a reputation for some absolute legbreaker tackles and a few deserved red cards to boot.
I think it's a bit rich to say that Berisha is too grubby for us. We're not pure and haven't been for a long time. I'm not saying there's any particular bad culture, but let's stop pretending we're on some sort of pedestal for behaviour. That was a part of our club identity when we started, and I was really proud of that, but that's well in the past.
Personally, I'm not too worried by any confrontation Berisha may have had with teammates 10+ years ago. And he's much more mellow than he was at Brisbane Roar, where he was a lot more aggro (although again, at least he usually didn't really go out to intentionally injure anybody), and he's cut the diving out of his game. He seems to be more mature in that sense (bit surprising under Muscat). He's still one of the villains of the game, IMO, but the game needs villains - and he doesn't actually really do anything that harms the game's image. Unlike O'Donovan, Muscat - even Brosque with his constant diving.
He's the sort of player I'll hate when he's somewhere else, but I'd get behind here. He's an arrogant bastard, but he can back up the talk too. Not like Muscat, where I'd be abusing him as long he's within earshot even if he wore yellow. And there's been a couple of players who I'd still despise even in our colours. Danny Tiato back from the early season comes to mind (Queensland Muscat)
He's got a bit of mungrel, and he's clearly a highly passionate player - moreso than most. I would imagine he'd be a hard trainer and one of those players who hangs around after training running skills. Not to mention that he has spent a lot of time in teams far more professional than ours has been and a lot of big game experience. Somebody like him would be valuable off the field as well as on.
For me, the only real issue is that he's on his downhill slide. Although, I imagine that even on his downhill slide he'd still be our top goalscorer if he was with us this season. Because he's still at a higher point of the downhill than our other downhill slide striker, and we still have nobody else who is proven to score goals.