Interesting stats - Breeze v Mariners

[soundsdifferent]

i just went over evry single time we have played newcastle since the a league begun and about half the time mathew breeze is the ref and we never win when he is

this shows he has huge tendancies

 

[marinermick]

These are stats for the last eight games Matthew Breeze has reffed the Mariners:

8 games - 0 wins, 2 draws, 6 losses

Yellow card count - Mariners 20, opposition 12
Red card count - Mariners 3, opposition 0
Foul count - Mariners 132, opposition 107

Draw your own conclusions

 

[brett]

That is attrocious but to be fair no team should have to put up with him! No way he is top two in the country.

 

[marinermick]

That is attrocious but to be fair no team should have to put up with him! No way he is top two in the country.

and out of fairness i got my wife to pick eight randon numbers between 1 and 21 to analyse the difference:

8 games - 4 wins, 2 draws, 2 losses

Red card count - Mariners 3, opposition 2
Yellow card count - Mariners 15, opposition 23
Foul count - Mariners 128, opposition 132

 

[Wombat]

WOW!!

Those stats are alarming. So he's not just a bumbling clown, he's a deadset cheat.

 

[soundsdifferent]

 

[striker]

These are stats for the last eight games Matthew Breeze has reffed the Mariners:

8 games - 0 wins, 2 draws, 6 losses

Yellow card count - Mariners 20, opposition 12
Red card count - Mariners 3, opposition 0
Foul count - Mariners 132, opposition 107

Draw your own conclusions

Who's the Ref  with the second highest number of games at the Mariners and compare his stats against Breeze.

 

[rosko]

Going by a post in another thread... Our guys haven't beaten anyone with Breeze as ref.... 

 

[marinermick]

These are stats for the last eight games Matthew Breeze has reffed the Mariners:

8 games - 0 wins, 2 draws, 6 losses

Yellow card count - Mariners 20, opposition 12
Red card count - Mariners 3, opposition 0
Foul count - Mariners 132, opposition 107

Draw your own conclusions

Who's the Ref  with the second highest number of games at the Mariners and compare his stats against Breeze.

that would be mark shield (last four games against melbourne as well!):

8 games, 2 wins, 2 draws, 4 lossess

Red cards: Mariners 2, opposition 2
Yellow cards: Mariners 24, opposition 18
Foul count: Mariners 109, opposition 112

 

[thomas477]

When CCM vs NEW at Bluetongue Stadium in the World Club Championship Qualifier Mrdja broke Durante's leg, 3 years later and Talay does same thing to Heff, both only got yellow cards.

WHY THE f**k IS BREAKIN A GUY'S LEG ONLY A YELLOW CARD?

 

[thomas477]

They have, World Club Championship qualifier when Mrdja broke Andrew Durante's leg - Mariners won on penalties.

 

[marinermick]

When CCM vs NEW at Bluetongue Stadium in the World Club Championship Qualifier Mrdja broke Durante's leg, 3 years later and Talay does same thing to Heff, both only got yellow cards.

WHY THE f**k IS BREAKIN A GUY'S LEG ONLY A YELLOW CARD?

because both players were just unlucky - neither tackle was worthy of a red

 

[marinermick]

They have, World Club Championship qualifier when Mrdja broke Andrew Durante's leg - Mariners won on penalties.

they haven't won in the last eight with breeze

they did beat perth halfway through last year with breeze

 

[thomas477]

When CCM vs NEW at Bluetongue Stadium in the World Club Championship Qualifier Mrdja broke Durante's leg, 3 years later and Talay does same thing to Heff, both only got yellow cards.

WHY THE f**k IS BREAKIN A GUY'S LEG ONLY A YELLOW CARD?

because both players were just unlucky - neither tackle was worthy of a red

Okay - i still believe that the FFA should do something about when players injure other players.

I CANT WAIT TO SEE HEFF BACK!!!!

 

[kevrenor]

When CCM vs NEW at Bluetongue Stadium in the World Club Championship Qualifier Mrdja broke Durante's leg, 3 years later and Talay does same thing to Heff, both only got yellow cards.

WHY THE f**k IS BREAKIN A GUY'S LEG ONLY A YELLOW CARD?

because both players were just unlucky - neither tackle was worthy of a red

Disagree Mick, from we stood and the Fox coverage, Talay's was a swinging scythe of a reckless and dangerous tackle - very worthy of a red!

Having said that - the actual harm to a player has nothing to do with getting a card (of whatever colour). It is about how it breaches the laws of the game. You could technically get a red card without actually touching the player if the tackle under the rules was bad enough.

 

[thomas477]

When CCM vs NEW at Bluetongue Stadium in the World Club Championship Qualifier Mrdja broke Durante's leg, 3 years later and Talay does same thing to Heff, both only got yellow cards.

WHY THE f**k IS BREAKIN A GUY'S LEG ONLY A YELLOW CARD?

because both players were just unlucky - neither tackle was worthy of a red

Disagree Mick, from we we stood and the Fox coverage, Talay's was a swinging scythe of a reckless and dangerous tackle - very worthy of a red!

And Mrdja's?

 

[thomas477]

Ok

 

[marinermick]

When CCM vs NEW at Bluetongue Stadium in the World Club Championship Qualifier Mrdja broke Durante's leg, 3 years later and Talay does same thing to Heff, both only got yellow cards.

WHY THE f**k IS BREAKIN A GUY'S LEG ONLY A YELLOW CARD?

because both players were just unlucky - neither tackle was worthy of a red

Disagree Mick, from we we stood and the Fox coverage, Talay's was a swinging scythe of a reckless and dangerous tackle - very worthy of a red!

no more reckless than what you see week in week out in the a-league

if that was a red then we would get plenty in the competition

 

[marinermick]

When CCM vs NEW at Bluetongue Stadium in the World Club Championship Qualifier Mrdja broke Durante's leg, 3 years later and Talay does same thing to Heff, both only got yellow cards.

WHY THE f**k IS BREAKIN A GUY'S LEG ONLY A YELLOW CARD?

because both players were just unlucky - neither tackle was worthy of a red

Disagree Mick, from we we stood and the Fox coverage, Talay's was a swinging scythe of a reckless and dangerous tackle - very worthy of a red!

And Mrdja's?

late but not malicious

durante should have had more calcium as a kid

 

[kevrenor]

no more reckless than what you see week in week out in the a-league

if that was a red then we would get plenty in the competition

no more reckless than what you see week in week out in the a-league

if that was a red then we would get plenty in the competition

Lol, we DO!