RND 13 PERTH

[higdawg]

i love how one eyed supporters can be sometimes. that was a shocking tackle by boogard that could have broken his leg.
very happy to see a red card.

Sorry but every week worse tackles happen that are not punished - no studs up I think yellow

no studs up? wtf? he hit him with his studs above his ankle from behind. a tackle from behind is a red anyway.

 

[jaypee]

i love how one eyed supporters can be sometimes. that was a shocking tackle by boogard that could have broken his leg.
very happy to see a red card.

Sorry but every week worse tackles happen that are not punished - no studs up I think yellow

no studs up? wtf? he hit him with his studs above his ankle from behind. a tackle from behind is a red anyway.

Again - you a one eyed Perth supporter???

 

[David Votoupal]

Talk about getting out of jail. Does neither side any favours!

 

[jaypee]

i love how one eyed supporters can be sometimes. that was a shocking tackle by boogard that could have broken his leg.
very happy to see a red card.

Sorry but every week worse tackles happen that are not punished - no studs up I think yellow

no studs up? wtf? he hit him with his studs above his ankle from behind. a tackle from behind is a red anyway.

Read the rule book - IT DOES NOT STATE ANYWHERE A TACKLE FROM BEHIND IS A STRAIGHT RED - Please read the rule book

 

[higdawg]

i love how one eyed supporters can be sometimes. that was a shocking tackle by boogard that could have broken his leg.
very happy to see a red card.

Sorry but every week worse tackles happen that are not punished - no studs up I think yellow

no studs up? wtf? he hit him with his studs above his ankle from behind. a tackle from behind is a red anyway.

Again - you a one eyed Perth supporter???

nope, i'm a referee. that was a shocking tackle.

football doesn't have rules, it has laws.

 

[Redline]

Cant find the list, but we did it to the youth side as well...scored off an 87th min free kick to win 2-1.

Boogs tackle didn't look that bad off the streaming from an Iraqi website

And yeah...we have a phenomenal attack, but the defence is lacking atm...maybe Heff can bring some much needed guidance back...Wilko doesn't seem to be doing to much.

 

[higdawg]

a tackle from behind is deemed to be a tackle that endangers the safety of the opponent and is deemed as serious foul play.

 

[Omni]

If you hit someone studs up above the ankle that's dangerous play and a straight red card.

Also, he can't read the rule book, it doesn't exist. It would be the LAW book

 

[jaypee]

i love how one eyed supporters can be sometimes. that was a shocking tackle by boogard that could have broken his leg.
very happy to see a red card.

Sorry but every week worse tackles happen that are not punished - no studs up I think yellow

no studs up? wtf? he hit him with his studs above his ankle from behind. a tackle from behind is a red anyway.

Again - you a one eyed Perth supporter???

nope, i'm a referee. that was a shocking tackle.

football doesn't have rules, it has laws.

Whatever - glad you don't ref our games (and I play 1st Grade)

So every tackle from behind is a straight red - geeze you made 3 posts in total I'm thinking TROLL at the moment.... Sorry if you aren't but I don't see how its different from 6 other tackles in that game by both sides

Not disagreeing about LAW book rule book - Farken semantics

Happy to change my mind guys but I didn't see studs up. If it was then yes red.
BUT please don't argue that all tackjles from behind are RED

 

[Kimba]

Cant find the list, but we did it to the youth side as well...scored off an 87th min free kick to win 2-1.

Boogs tackle didn't look that bad off the streaming from an Iraqi website

And yeah...we have a phenomenal attack, but the defence is lacking atm...maybe Heff can bring some much needed guidance back...Wilko doesn't seem to be doing to much.

mmmmm Heff. We missed Pedj badly tonight also.

 

[jaypee]

a tackle from behind is deemed to be a tackle that endangers the safety of the opponent and is deemed as serious foul play.

Yes and serious Foul play is not deemed a straight red but is up to the discretion of the referee

 

[Redline]

TBH I haven't seen Pedj play much..haven't caught many games this season, but I know that Heffs experience could be a good settling factor for our back line.

 

[Kimba]

Pedj is one of Mr McKinna's signings of the season IMHO.

 

[Ted]

Pedj has been solid all season and we definately missed him tonight. Having Heff back would also be a great boost to our defence.

 

[Wheresdadspants?]

i love how one eyed supporters can be sometimes. that was a shocking tackle by boogard that could have broken his leg.
very happy to see a red card.

Sorry but every week worse tackles happen that are not punished - no studs up I think yellow

no studs up? wtf? he hit him with his studs above his ankle from behind. a tackle from behind is a red anyway.

Again - you a one eyed Perth supporter???

nope, i'm a referee. that was a shocking tackle.

football doesn't have rules, it has laws.

Twat. Must be a perth or scum supporter cause who would agree with anyone in yellw getting sent off.I thought the ref was fantastic but dunno if it was a straight red. As I said he's probably out with injury anyway and hopefully we get heff back next week definately pedj and maybe clarkey.

 

[Wheresdadspants?]

Pedj is one of Mr McKinna's signings of the season IMHO.

Same type of signing as when we got mile 2 seasons ago. Straight from the state league, tough, resiliant type of player who wears his heart on his sleeve and as tough as nails.

 

[Ted]

yep, clarky, wilko, pedj and heff would be sweet

 

[higdawg]

a tackle from behind is deemed to be a tackle that endangers the safety of the opponent and is deemed as serious foul play.

Yes and serious Foul play is not deemed a straight red but is up to the discretion of the referee

you lecture me about needing to read the laws and then post this.


he hit him above the ankle from behind. its nothing but serious foul play.

 

[jaypee]

i love how one eyed supporters can be sometimes. that was a shocking tackle by boogard that could have broken his leg.
very happy to see a red card.

Sorry but every week worse tackles happen that are not punished - no studs up I think yellow

no studs up? wtf? he hit him with his studs above his ankle from behind. a tackle from behind is a red anyway.

Again - you a one eyed Perth supporter???

nope, i'm a referee. that was a shocking tackle.

football doesn't have rules, it has laws.

Twat. Must be a perth or scum supporter cause who would agree with anyone in yellw getting sent off.I thought the ref was fantastic but dunno if it was a straight red. As I said he's probably out with injury anyway and hopefully we get heff back next week definately pedj and maybe clarkey.

yep - he's made three posts and each one arguing it was a RED

FROM THE LAW BOOK

Disciplinary sanctions
If a player plays in a dangerous manner in a normal challenge,
the referee should not take any disciplinary action. If the action is
made with obvious risk of injury, the referee should caution the
player

So the question is was it normal or not - I need to see it more...

 

[jaypee]

a tackle from behind is deemed to be a tackle that endangers the safety of the opponent and is deemed as serious foul play.

FROM THE LAW Book


Yes and serious Foul play is not deemed a straight red but is up to the discretion of the referee

you lecture me about needing to read the laws and then post this.


he hit him above the ankle from behind. its nothing but serious foul play.

Disciplinary sanctions
If a player plays in a dangerous manner in a normal challenge,
the referee should not take any disciplinary action. If the action is
made with obvious risk of injury, the referee should caution the
player

Happy to be convinced it was Serious Foul play - Just don't agree it was after looking at it twice
Go back to your own forum...