Rd23 - Roar @ Suncorp

Josho Howe

Well-Known Member
Refs faulting is meaningless. Couple of clear chances on the counter. DDS needed to give it to Muzz. I know we're all critical of his finishing but l think he would have finished that off. Had time and space and was on a good angle. We are our own worst enemy not the officials.
 

marinermick

Well-Known Member
That’s an outrageous decision, how is that a clear and obvious error. Yet again we have to deal with rubbish refereeing!!
Offside doesn’t go by the obvious error philosophy. You either are or you’re not, even if centremetres are involved.

Unfortunately this was onside.
 

Ads

Active Member
I’m after consistency still.
We had many instances over last 4 weeks that didn’t even get looked at.

But when I watch other games the Var checking seems much more even and consistent
 

neverwozza

Active Member
I thought it was onside but too close to overturn the AR on the clear and obvious error principal. It seems as though there are some rules for us and some rules for other clubs and KGJ is still a miserable prick.
 

marinermick

Well-Known Member
I thought it was onside but too close to overturn the AR on the clear and obvious error principal. It seems as though there are some rules for us and some rules for other clubs and KGJ is still a miserable prick.
Clear and obvious error doesn’t apply to offside. You either are or you’re not because there is no interpretation over the ruling.
 

possum x

Member
Call me nuts but I do feel Melling and Shabow were harshly done by to be completely forgotten about this season. They both looked competent enough to get a run most weeks and at least they'd put in the effort in a time of desperation.

I'll be devastated if we lose Ziggy. He's a fantastic asset to the club and the younger guys should feed off of his professionalism.
I get the feeling you're not the full quid champ
 

Ads

Active Member
Silvera must have a clause of game time to help secure his sale / deal.

No other reason can be justified.
 

ashman89

Active Member
Sorry fellas I tried to make the line as best as I could. Looks onside to me. Very very unfortunate.

Feedback on my line drawing is welcome. Drew from back of clisby’s heel right foot

I also welcome foxsports contacting me for a career in VAR offside line drawing

50F9C8A1-43E2-4F91-9515-F8E765F326CC.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Top