Our Beloved Monty

[Allreet?]

If they got 40 odd CVs for the job, then I presume Cahn did not submit his own application but was approached.

Why else would he say no?

 

[sydmariner]

If they got 40 odd CVs for the job, then I presume Cahn did not submit his own application but was approached.

Why else would he say no?

he must have a good thing going on at melbourne nights'.

 

[Corsair]

If they got 40 odd CVs for the job, then I presume Cahn did not submit his own application but was approached.

Why else would he say no?

Money?

 

[Tevor]

Yeah will need more concrete info on Cahn apparently saying no. I don’t not believe it but I don’t want to get carried away. It would kind of make sense given Knights have a genuine chance of making aus cup final… I dunno.

IMO I think our case is special in that, there possibly could be a foreign applicant but would they completely buy into the coast, the club and the academy? The smooth transition is so crucial in these moments for a small club with a largely established successful squad.

The first reason Monty had success was he knew the club inside and out. And then with some help basically built the academy to where it is..
Abbas only would have a good grasp of what the clubs about given he hasn’t been here 12months yet, but more importantly knows the academy inside and out. He’s my #1 candidate at this point. It’s good to hear from a couple people that the squad are trusting in him already.

I don’t want Talay near our footy club, either. Or any failed recycled aleague manager.

You have a misconception of Talay if you think he failed. Do you not recall him making Monty very much look like a first time inexperienced manager in some games. He also isn’t recycled in my opinion, he did three years at Nix and wanted to come home. Compare that to Rudan who jumped ship as soon as he could.

 

[Jimmy]

Heard on the grapevine that Cahn said no… ?

Heard from Cahn that this is not true.

 

[pjennings]

Money?

He could be on decent money, Knights might be in NST next season, any number of reasons. I hope he is still in the race though.

 

[Meerkat]

Heard from Cahn that this is not true.

My source is to date, pretty well 100% accurate.. would be happy for this to be a ding in his otherwise faultless rep!!! ?

 

[Big Al]

Was a media thing of Cahn playing a straight bat. I am only interested in my second child being born in a day and the semi but it was not a no.

 

[Michael]

You have a misconception of Talay if you think he failed. Do you not recall him making Monty very much look like a first time inexperienced manager in some games. He also isn’t recycled in my opinion, he did three years at Nix and wanted to come home. Compare that to Rudan who jumped ship as soon as he could.

Sorry I should’ve phrased it better, I don’t think talay had failed at all.
But I don’t believe he’s the right manager for us.

 

[Pirate Pete]

Money?

Just my thoughts. But I would imagine some coaches wouldn't worry about the money.
Isn't it ego, or whatever. Striving to do better. The challenge etc.

 

[Tevor]

Sorry I should’ve phrased it better, I don’t think talay had failed at all.
But I don’t believe he’s the right manager for us.

All good I get there are mixed feelings on him.

 

[Insertnamehere]

I mean Talay had an arguably better team on paper and still got found out. Do we want a guy who gets his team to week 1 of finals or finishes just shy? Is that a pass mark?

 

[FFC Mariner]

All good I get there are mixed feelings on him.

People with memories dont want the SFC grub anywhere near us.
He is only waiting for the SFC job anyway. Big Monday call. Its not him regardless of what his media mates say.
He will be too expensive.
(Thats not based on anything other than my dislike of him. I just cant see CCM doing it)

 

[Jimmy]

My source is to date, pretty well 100% accurate.. would be happy for this to be a ding in his otherwise faultless rep!!! ?

I don't want to hurt any chances Ben has, so I won't say anything more.

But, I'd question why you're hearing he's said no.
Would it be an easy excuse for not picking the fan's (and obvious) choice.

 

[BrisRecky]

People with memories dont want the SFC grub anywhere near us.
He is only waiting for the SFC job anyway. Big Monday call. Its not him regardless of what his media mates say.
He will be too expensive.
(Thats not based on anything other than my dislike of him. I just cant see CCM doing it)

yes he done adequate at the NIx BUT I still dont want the Sonic snapping f**ktard anywhere near the place

 

[Meerkat]

I don't want to hurt any chances Ben has, so I won't say anything more.

But, I'd question why you're hearing he's said no.
Would it be an easy excuse for not picking the fan's (and obvious) choice.

Well, possibly. But if it’s not true, surely that truth is always going to come out.

 

[midfielder]

It would be a brave coach of a state team, to knock back and offer to coach an A-L team ,especially given the squad is not that weak.

Personally I can't see it happening....

I can only assume a short list has been drawn up and interviews are taking place.... BC seems to be a crowd fav, be interesting to know if the powers also have a similar view of his talent...

 

[adz]

I think it might be time for a new topic rather than spreading rumours about offers being knocked back. We seem to be going around in circles a bit now.

 

[shipwreck]

It's not the Mariners way to stand in an Individual's development.

Unfortunately this means that contracts mean nothing.

 

[adz]

It's not the Mariners way to stand in an Individual's development.

Unfortunately this means that contracts mean nothing.

Yeah I removed my post - just having a whinge