Captaincy Chaos: Kaltak's Armband Controversy!

[adz]

Thanks for starting such a great conversation @Lexi - it’s brought up some really interesting points

We’ve established that the captaincy change was part of the original plan, but there’s still a lot to think about when it comes to what makes a good captain. eg. does anyone think the captaincy itself could be a burden that impacts a player’s performance? Could having that responsibility either motivate a player or weigh them down?

There’s also the question of what leadership on the field should look like. Should a captain be vocal and directing play, or is it more about leading through example and presence? And how much of that leadership should be obvious to us watching from the stands?

And what do people think about the idea of "earning" the captaincy? Should it always go to the most experienced or skilled player, or are there other factors to consider?

What’s everyone’s take on all this?

 

[FFC Mariner]

Thanks for starting such a great conversation @Lexi - it’s brought up some really interesting points

We’ve established that the captaincy change was part of the original plan, but there’s still a lot to think about when it comes to what makes a good captain. eg. does anyone think the captaincy itself could be a burden that impacts a player’s performance? Could having that responsibility either motivate a player or weigh them down?

There’s also the question of what leadership on the field should look like. Should a captain be vocal and directing play, or is it more about leading through example and presence? And how much of that leadership should be obvious to us watching from the stands?

And what do people think about the idea of "earning" the captaincy? Should it always go to the most experienced or skilled player, or are there other factors to consider?

What’s everyone’s take on all this?

I tend to use copilot more than GPT

 

[adz]

I tend to use copilot more than GPT

I'd rate Gemini higher than Copilot, but each to their own. The main thing is, it's not really helpful to shut down new people straight away when they ask questions that might be a bit controversial to the group. It just makes it harder to grow the community and encourage more discussions.

 

[Stuartmcateer]

I'd rate Gemini higher than Copilot, but each to their own. The main thing is, it's not really helpful to shut down new people straight away when they ask questions that might be a bit controversial to the group. It just makes it harder to grow the community and encourage more discussions.

Surely Lexi came across and said hello at alliance on Saturday 🤔

 

[adz]

You guys are a cynical bunch, aren’t you! 🤣

 

[Wombat]

Agree, we all knew that, but why? Kaltak did a great job. I went to the game at Alliance on Saturday night, Kaltak kept gesturing and directing the backs, but I can't say I noticed too much hand-movement or talking from the Capatin to the rest of the team

Kaltak is close to being dropped. He has played well in maybe 2 games. Average in most and shocking in a few.