Good opinion piece from Les Murray regarding the flying choppers.
http://theworldgame.sbs.com.au/sydneys-plunge-into-a-dark-past-107958/
Sydney's plunge into a dark past
By Les Murray | 10 March 2008 | 10:10
Around a year ago, soon after the sacking of Terry Butcher, I filed a column for this space in an attempt to explain why Sydney FC was a managerial basket case and had been since its inception.
In it I called for a revolution, a re-think of what makes a truly great and class club, as opposed to what Sydney had been, a blinkered, pedestrian outfit driven only by results, as if the habit of winning, no matter what ugly way it was achieved, was the only building block of greatness.
What has changed?
Not that much, to be blunt.
The recent signing of Mark Bridge, Simon Colosimo and John Aloisi suggests Sydney may have rediscovered its birthright to be ambitious and is again investing in quality and glamour.
And it's true, Bridge is one of the league's most exciting young strikers, Colosimo is a thoroughly versatile and highly experienced player, and Aloisi - well, we all know how marketable he has become since 'that' penalty and his memorable World Cup goal against Japan.
But one has to ask, which of these three players will transform Sydney's brand of football into one of ritzy entertainment, elegance and class?
Juninho is gone, along with the deft dribble, the delicate through-pass, the bent free kicks, and the magnetism of a World Cup winner. He has been replaced by John Aloisi, a powerful, muscular finisher whose career high point, with respect, was Osasuna.
In any case who, in the absence of Juninho and the diminishing stamina of Corica, will supply the ball for Aloisi's finishing, God only knows.
If this plunge by Sydney into the player market gives you hidden reminders of a mini-Galacticos policy by a mini-Real Madrid, perish the thought.
Madrid's extravagant shopping spree under that policy brought it Figo, Zidane, Ronaldo and Beckham, all players of great entertainment value, class and enduring magnetism. Moreover they were perfect fits for madridismo, Reals age old tradition of needing to win with chic and class.
This is not what is driving Sydney FC and never has.
Sydney, self-dubbed as the 'glamour' team of the A-League even before it was launched, should have long ago sent emissaries, if not to Madrid, to some of the model clubs of Europe and elsewhere, even Japan, to study what makes a truly great club.
Instead they have gone back to the influence of a different model: Sydney City of the early 1980s.
I have news for them. That won't help make Sydney FC a great club.
At the top end of Sydney FC's managerial and coaching tree is a clear infatuation with the old Sydney City which won three NSL titles in its golden era.
Part of the secret of that success was in Sydney City's policy and ability to simply sign up the NSL's finest young playing talent from wherever it saw them. The policy was driven by the late Andrew Lederer, the multi-millionaire smallgoods king, who could spot a good player of serious potential when he saw him.
Lederer brought to Sydney the cream of the era's Australian football talent: John Kosmina, Ken Boden, David Mitchell, Frank Farina, Jimmy Cant and Jean-Paul de Marigny.
It was this, plus the wily coaching gifts of a young Eddie Thomson, that brought Sydney City its results and its titles.
But Sydney FC's nostalgic policy makers of today forget one small thing: the 1980s vintage Sydney City was pilloried for a distinctly unattractive brand of football, the ugliness of which left it with barely a few hundred regular fans, despite the trophies.
The home leg of its two-legged NSL grand final of 1985, against Brunswick, with Kosmina, Farina and Mitchell all on view, was attended by 2,491 people. Shortly after Frank Lowy, then president of the team's financial backer, the Hakoah Club, shut down the football operation because of its drain on the bottom line.
In an interview with Lowy at the time, I asked him, wasn't it the Hakoah Club's original remit and raison d'etre to run a football team?
He said, 'Oh yes, a football team. But for whom?'
It is this policy with which Sydney FC is now toying.
They are signing 'name' players, for which alone they should not be criticised. That is one of the things so-called glamour clubs do.
But they are doing it without an eye on empirical entertainment value and lateral planning.
They have a coach, in John Kosmina, another Sydney City throwback, who gets results and has a brilliant gift for getting blood sacrifice out of his players, but who never talks about winning with glory and style, only about winning.
They sign players of profile and talent but how exactly those players fit into a grander package, a broad box-office blueprint, is not considered. If it works, and I doubt it, it will be by pure accident.
Sydney FC doesn't entertain and never has. It just fights.
What Sydney FC's numerous, but tyrannically fickle and demanding fans want is not just big names, or even results. They are too proud for that. They want to roll up to the SFS knowing their team is the elite of the elite, and that it doesn't just chase results but plays with the kind of poise and swagger that is the model for the rest.
Aping the battling and bruising Sydney City of 1983 will not achieve any of that and is a waste of time and money.