Treble Winners v Scummiest Scum To Ever Scum

[Stuartmcateer]

What's your point?

That kaltak hasn't been the brick wall of Gosford this year.

And when he has been poor the blame has been shifted or excused as him having to organise or cover for other players.

 

[FFC Mariner]

Paull is a wide left footed CB in a modern 343.
He is not a LB or LWB.

 

[Stuartmcateer]

Paull is a wide left footed CB in a modern 343.
He is not a LB or LWB.

We haven't had many crosses from the left as good as the one he provided in Tarneit.🤣🤣🤣

 

[Corsair]

That kaltak hasn't been the brick wall of Gosford this year.

And when he has been poor the blame has been shifted or excused as him having to organise or cover for other players.

I see, so when I say I don't think Paull is yet up to Aleague standard at Centre back you're saying he is but he gets the blame for Brian's mistakes which makes people think he isnt as good as he really is. That's your opinion, I'm not of the same opinion.

I'm not some huge Kaltak fan, I think he's a good player who is guaranteed to make a mistake eventually. His weakness is being pressed and rushed. Paull is better at playing out and that's part of why I think he's shining at LB. Also turns out he can cross well and is a decent goal hanger. Keep him at LB.

 

[Spacks]

Stats don't tell you how well a player positions himself or reads play. I agree Brian has had some poor games as well this season.

Ability to read the game would lead to higher interceptions. Ability to read the game can be a natural skill or acquired from experience, no?

 

[Corsair]

Paull is a wide left footed CB in a modern 343.
He is not a LB or LWB.

Furthest left at the back is what I call LB even if it's a 3 so I probably word that incorrectly.

 

[VonBowellski]

He’s also possibly our best striker 😂

😳

Besides Owen G

 

[Corsair]

Ability to read the game would lead to higher interceptions. Ability to read the game can be a natural skill or acquired from experience, no?

Yes and I've said before that I don't think Paull reads the game well as a natural talent. It might improve with time, positioning is similar. As a defender at 21 I thought he'd be further along than he is but maybe he didn't get a lot of game time before joining us.

I'm not ragging on him I think he's playing well at the moment, now he's out of that CB role he looks a lot more comfortable.

 

[Stuartmcateer]

I see, so when I say I don't think Paull is yet up to Aleague standard at Centre back you're saying he is but he gets the blame for Brian's mistakes which makes people think he isnt as good as he really is. That's your opinion, I'm not of the same opinion.

No. What I am saying is that he is developing into a player who could be a solid a league standard defender. I'm not saying he is prime Maldini.

What I am also saying, is that when Brian sits on the 6 yard box and doesn't mark anyone, that to blame paull for conceding the goal, without even acknowledging the part such poor positioning had on the goal being conceded, is a poor bit of analysis. Also that the second goal is not just that nata won the header - the dismal playing at the back and conceding of the corner directly contributed to the goal. Ignoring that and pinning it on Paull is just plain BS.

And there is countless times this year that Brian's errors have been excused because he was under the debilitating effect of captaincy or playing next to Paull (even when some of his biggest gaffes this year were when he was playing next to tapp or sains - can't blame Paull for the honking defending against Sydney as he didn't even play).

 

[FFC Mariner]

Yes and I've said before that I don't think Paull reads the game well as a natural talent. It might improve with time, positioning is similar. As a defender at 21 I thought he'd be further along than he is but maybe he didn't get a lot of game time before joining us.

I'm not ragging on him I think he's playing well at the moment, now he's out of that CB role he looks a lot more comfortable.

He's not out of the CB role. We play with 3, he is one of them.

 

[Corsair]

No. What I am saying is that he is developing into a player who could be a solid a league standard defender. I'm not saying he is prime Maldini.

What I am also saying, is that when Brian sits on the 6 yard box and doesn't mark anyone, that to blame paull for conceding the goal, without even acknowledging the part such poor positioning had on the goal being conceded, is a poor bit of analysis. Also that the second goal is not just that nata won the header - the dismal playing at the back and conceding of the corner directly contributed to the goal. Ignoring that and pinning it on Paull is just plain BS.

And there is countless times this year that Brian's errors have been excused because he was under the debilitating effect of captaincy or playing next to Paull (even when some of his biggest gaffes this year were when he was playing next to tapp or sains - can't blame Paull for the honking defending against Sydney as he didn't even play).

Yeah OK i wasnt being specific about that game so you're still on about posts with cap, fair enough.

 

[capauau]

He's not out of the CB role. We play with 3, he is one of them.

His defending hasn't improved as much as his attacking ability.
Perhaps having Josh Rose on the coaching team has helped his go forward

 

[Spacks]

His defending hasn't improved as much as his attacking ability.
Perhaps having Josh Rose on the coaching team has helped his go forward

That run up the left wing was very much Rose-esque xD

 

[Corsair]

He's not out of the CB role. We play with 3, he is one of them.

Does not compute. Old git can't comprehend 3 CB's 😀 Its one CB a RB and LB! (Yes I know it's 3 CB's really but it leaves me with Vicky Pollard syndrome, yeah but no but yeah but no but....!)

 

[Corsair]

WTH has happened to Mauragis anyway? Does anyone know?

 

[Spacks]

WTH has happened to Mauragis anyway? Does anyone know?

Injured.

 

[Ironbark]

FTS