R15 - F3 Derby #46 (Away)

[Woollybutt]

Can anyone explain the relationship between Fox and VAR? Because on both Newcastle's offside goal and the handball shout, and I think against Wellington as well, Fox showed a replay much later that showed the decision was wrong. Does Fox control what angles VAR sees? I've never understood how that works.

 

[pjennings]

Nisbet showed that he belongs in the HAL - sign him up on a multi-year deal now.

 

[JoyfulPenguin]

Nisbet showed that he belongs in the HAL - sign him up on a multi-year deal now.

Three year deal with triggers for longer for me.

 

[Ancient Mariner]

Shit result.

Good scrappy performance, lots of encouraging signs. Speaking of which I would like to see some "signs" on new contracts.

Pain, Millar Hiariej, O'Neil, Aspro, Murray and NISBET.

 

[shipwreck]

Standby for us to f**k up Nisbet as well

 

[Capn Gus Bloodbeard]

Can anyone explain the relationship between Fox and VAR? Because on both Newcastle's offside goal and the handball shout, and I think against Wellington as well, Fox showed a replay much later that showed the decision was wrong. Does Fox control what angles VAR sees? I've never understood how that works.

We don't get to see what the VAR sees until it goes to onfield review.

So we might not be looking at the same footage. Which is absolutely stupid.

 

[Woollybutt]

Shit result.

Good scrappy performance, lots of encouraging signs. Speaking of which I would like to see some "signs" on new contracts.

Pain, Millar Hiariej, O'Neil, Aspro, Murray and NISBET.

Those seven plus Rowles, Shabow, and Kekeris would be the core of a decent squad for the next couple of years. I just really, really want it to be our squad for once.

 

[Woollybutt]

We don't get to see what the VAR sees until it goes to onfield review.

So we might not be looking at the same footage. Which is absolutely stupid.

Cheers. So either VAR didn't get to see those angles (in which case how the hell can we have any trust in it as a system) or they did see them and ignored them, and we'll never get to know which it was. Sounds like FFA's typical approach to transparency.

 

[Insertnamehere]

Kinda not fussed about the grella taking Rowles to citeh, now we have Aspro fit. He is absolute quality.

 

[Capn Gus Bloodbeard]

Those seven plus Rowles, Shabow, and Kekeris would be the core of a decent squad for the next couple of years. I just really, really want it to be our squad for once.

Agree. Watch us sign Hoole, Cisse, Kennedy and Golec as the core of our squad.

 

[LFCMariners]

Jets fans should buy a lotto ticket with their next Centrelink payment. If they play like that the rest of the season, I don't see where their next win/s will come from besides Brisbane and maybe WSW?

A decent striker would've made all the difference for CCM tonight. Form has been much better overall since the Nix game, at this point I'd say the spoon battle is soon to be WSW v Roar. CCM should nab enough draws/ wins to put us free...

 

[Insertnamehere]

Agree. Watch us sign Hoole, Cisse, Kennedy and Golec as the core of our squad.

Add weemac... And Melling
I'd keep golec personally unless his leg is absolutely fkd.

 

[JoyfulPenguin]

Kinda not fussed about the grella taking Rowles to citeh fuss now we have Aspro fit. He is absolute quality.

Bring Crestani from NPLQ in, was better than Rowles at Roar.

 

[Woollybutt]

Agree. Watch us sign Hoole, Cisse, Kennedy and Golec as the core of our squad.

Ouch. Too close to the bone.

 

[JoyfulPenguin]

Add weemac... And Melling
I'd keep golec personally unless his leg is absolutely fkd.

A fit Golec with a full pre season behind him would be a good starting centre back.

 

[Insertnamehere]

Bring Crestani from NPLQ in, was better than Rowles at Roar.

We'll be doing bulk trials in the off season again. We'll be the NPL stepping stone.
Bring in transfer fees

 

[Capn Gus Bloodbeard]

Add weemac... And Melling
I'd keep golec personally unless his leg is absolutely fkd.

I wouldn't. But I'm the only person who thought he was terrible last season too.

 

[Ancient Mariner]

Add weemac... And Melling
I'd keep golec personally unless his leg is absolutely fkd.

Melling had an ordinary 1st half but was good in the second. I thought he was good last week as well.
I have been one of his biggest critics but will give credit where it is due.
I will watch the replay for a better idea before saying more.

 

[Coastalraider]

I’m hoping tonight was a watershed for MM. while he persisted with Cisse and Golec for too long, once the penny dropped we haven’t seen them since.

Hopefully tonight watching a couple of kids in Kekeris and Nisbett will drop the penny that WeeMac and Hoole are taking the piss.

Those 2 are good depth. When fit, a squad of:
Kennedy (only because we have to)
Millar/New CD/Aspro/Rowles/Pain
Karacan/O’Neill
Hiarijai
Murray/Oar/Pain
Simon

With Clisby/Nisbett/Shabow/Kekeris/Pearce

I’d be fairly happy with that given we are only likely to make 1 more CD signing this year. And my favourite part is who is NOT required to create that lineup - WeeMac, Hoole,Melling,Cisse.

 

[Insertnamehere]

What other yoof we got that go as good as kekeris and Nisbet?