If you could pinch 3 players from another HAL team who would you take>

[Wombat]

Again looking at the other HAL Squads on wekipedia. If you could bolster your squad by raiding 3 players from a rivals team....who would you pinch.

For me i'd look at swiping the following:

Scum: Culina, Topor- Stanley and Elrich.
Adelaide: Djitte, McKain and Galekovic
Glory: Smeltz, Stejovski and Travis Dodd.
Victory: Kewell, Thompson and Hernadez
Heart: Bolton, Colosimo and Fred (or williams if Fred is washed up)
Sydney: Emerton, Carle and Beauchamp
Nix: Ifil, Bertos and Durante
Roar: Theoklitos, Broich and Smith (rock solid if unspectacular)
fold Coast: Twaite, Rigters and Minnecon (probably wouldn't bother with any of them)


And conversely, who would you pinch from us:

I'd tip Dutchy, Rose and Olly would probably be the first taken.

Who who you grab?

 

[some guy]

newcastle: wehrman, elrich, jesic
adelaide: ramsay, djite, mckain
glory: dodd, smeltz, neville (or vukovic, but mat ryan is a more than capable replacement)
victory: rojas, kewell, celeski
heart: terra, colosimo, m. thompson
sydney: emerton, carle, jamieson
wellington: ifill, daniel, downey
brisbane: dont want any of them
gc: thwaite, porter, mebrahtu

us: zwaanswijk, mcglinchey, griffiths (although i could easily name more)

 

[garlo]

Newcastle: topor Stanley
Adelaide: vidosic galekovic Ramsay
Glory: tbh wouldn't take any of them except maybe danny
Victory: kewell
Heart: Williams dugandzic Thompson
Phoenix: ifill Durante
Fold: minniecon thwaite golgol
Roar: paartalu broich
Sydney: emo kisel beauchamp

It's quite hard to pick three for each team !
Rosey glinch and dutchy from us ..or wilko instead of dutchy seeing as dutchy won't be around long
Great thread Wombat !!

 

[tsd]

i am going to take a different approach if i may... 3 players that would strengthen our team the most from the entire a-league... leaving out harry and emmo as they are too obvious!

what spots in our starting 11 are the weakest? second striker we would all say but where else?

mmm

smelts to partner matty, Broich but play him central and franjic at right back?

 

[garlo]

I forgot about franjic ...real quality

 

[Forum Phoenix]

Sorry Wombat, but I vomited all over my keyboard as soon as I read the first line about swiping Culina from Scum.

 

[Wombat]

Sorry Wombat, but I vomited all over my keyboard as soon as I read the first line about swiping Culina from Scum.

Yes, he is a dick. Yes he is now a scummer.....BUT he is a quality player.
You would have to select him if picking from Scum's squad.

He's out for season anyway so I'm sorry you damaged your keyboard over nothing

The whole point of the topic was to spark some debate because it's been quiet on here lately.