HAL All Stars '09

[bjw]

http://mk.footballaustralia.com.au/mk/get/HAL_ALL_STARS_09

Post teams here
___________________________________________________________________

My team

Theo
Bojic, Og-monster, Moore, McKain
Caceres, Jedinak, Dodd, Musialik
Rukyvistya, Smeltz

Coach: Vidmar.

 

[Redline]

I hate that you *have* to use 4-4-2. It's a crap formation.

Danny
Costanzo Moore Mullen Ognenovski
Kruse Daniel Tiatto Jedinak
Mrdja Petrovski

McKinna as coach of course.

 

[mariners4ever]

I hate that you *have* to use 4-4-2. It's a crap formation.

Danny
Costanzo Moore Mullen Ognenovski
Kruse Daniel Tiatto Jedinak
Mrdja Petrovski

McKinna as coach of course.

why mrdja

 

[Paolo]

I hate that you *have* to use 4-4-2. It's a crap formation.

Danny
Costanzo Moore Mullen Ognenovski
Kruse Daniel Tiatto Jedinak
Mrdja Petrovski

McKinna as coach of course.

why mrdja

ill add to this...why have two CBs playing LB and RB?
Why is jedinak at LM?
Why Kruse?
Why Petrovski?
Why mullen in CB?
Why Danny?

 

[marinermick]

Galekovic
Elrich.T - Moore - Og - McKain
Dodd - Miller - Jedinak - Pellegrino
Smeltz - Simon

Team is rigid as you were only allowed certain players in certain positions and 4-4-2.

 

[Jorome Alexander Bennett]

Countryhick??

Galekovic
Elrich.T - Moore - Og - McKain
Dodd - Miller - Jedinak - Pellegrino
Smeltz - Simon

Team is rigid as you were only allowed certain players in certain positions and 4-4-2.

I like the look of that a lot.

Would you ideally play McKain as left back? What about Jamieson? I can't look past his annoying impetuousness, but many see this as youthful exuberance that makes up for lack of experience.

Am I being heavily biased when I assess Simon as great, ie. could make it at Celtic, for example? He may not be pretty (no offense intended), but he is gorram effective. The way he chests the ball and continues movement towards goal scoring angles, in particular, can hardly be defended against. His annoying impetuosness has matured into hard work hassling to force errors when required.

 

[marinermick]

Countryhick??

Galekovic
Elrich.T - Moore - Og - McKain
Dodd - Miller - Jedinak - Pellegrino
Smeltz - Simon

Team is rigid as you were only allowed certain players in certain positions and 4-4-2.

I like the look of that a lot.

Would you ideally play McKain as left back? What about Jamieson? I can't look past his annoying impetuousness, but many see this as youthful exuberance that makes up for lack of experience.

Am I being heavily biased when I assess Simon as great, ie. could make it at Celtic, for example? He may not be pretty (no offense intended), but he is gorram effective. The way he chests the ball and continues movement towards goal scoring angles, in particular, can hardly be defended against. His annoying impetuosness has matured into hard work hassling to force errors when required.

no, wouldn't play mckain there as the website didn't allow me to change systems and i have one too many attacking outside mid for my liking

with those players i would probably go:

galekovic
elrich - moore - og
-- mckain --- mile ---
dodd - miller - pelligrino
--- smeltz -- simon---

it still doesn't look right with tarek in a back three but he did do ok in that position and formation for newcastle friday night
elrich -

 

[Redline]

I didn't necessarily pick players specifically in their best position, I'm not up on whether someone is a LM or a CM and stuff like that. I don't have the memory for that sort of stuff.

Mrdja was a mistake...I thought I put Simon...I wanted a tall man, and Sash as he has a lot of experience and still plays relatively well.

Kruse because I like his speed on the wing. He's shown a great ability to break down the wing and get a cross in over many games.

Mullen at CB and Jedinak at LM see above in this post.

Danny because IMO he has the potential to be one of the best keepers we produce in Australia. Provided he doesn't incur more of a disciplinary record then he already has as I think that would factor into considering him, or not, for a National team spot, and maybe even for O/S clubs looking around at him.